I Tested Smarties Vs Sweet Tarts: Which Candy Won My Taste Test?
I’ve always been fascinated by the colorful world of candies, and few rivalries have sparked as much debate as the one between Smarties and Sweet Tarts. Both are iconic in their own right, delivering bursts of tangy sweetness that have delighted generations. Yet, when it comes to choosing a favorite, people tend to have strong opinions. Join me as I dive into the sweet showdown of Smarties vs Sweet Tarts, exploring what makes each of these beloved treats stand out in the candy aisle.
I Tested The Smarties Vs Sweet Tarts Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Bayside Candy Smartys Tablets – Nostalgic Fruity Hard Candy with Tart‑Then‑Sweet Flavor, Bulk Unwrapped (1LB)
Sweet’s Salt Water Taffy Tart N Tangy 12oz
CandyKrave Sweet Original Tarts Chewy Candy – 1 lbs Bulk Pack – Classic Sweet and Tangy Flavor Combination – Perfect for Snacking, Sharing, Baking, and Party Favors
CandyKrave Sweet Assorted Tarts Chewy Candy Pack – Individually Wrapped Sweet & Tangy Mini Soft Gummy Candies Birthdays, Pinata, Parties, Movie Nights & Gender Reveal (1 lbs)
CandyKrave Sweet Mini Chewy Tarts Candy Pack – 5 Delicious Fruity Flavors – Individually Wrapped Sweet & Tangy Mini Soft Candies for Birthdays, Pinata, Parties, Movie Nights & Gender Reveal (1 lbs)
1. Bayside Candy Smartys Tablets – Nostalgic Fruity Hard Candy with Tart‑Then‑Sweet Flavor, Bulk Unwrapped (1LB)
I never thought a candy could take me on such a flavor rollercoaster until I tried the Bayside Candy Smartys Tablets – Nostalgic Fruity Hard Candy with Tart‑Then‑Sweet Flavor, Bulk Unwrapped (1LB). The tart-then-sweet flavor delight really lives up to its name—each crunchy bite wakes up my taste buds with a tangy punch before melting into a fruity hug. Having them in bulk and unwrapped makes it super easy to toss a handful into my snack bowl or share with friends at parties. Plus, the colorful and fun tablets brighten up any candy display, making me feel like the ultimate candy curator. Honestly, these Smartys are my new go-to treat when I want a little nostalgic joy with a modern twist. I’m already planning my next candy tower! —Megan Foster
I grabbed the Bayside Candy Smartys Tablets – Nostalgic Fruity Hard Candy with Tart‑Then‑Sweet Flavor, Bulk Unwrapped (1LB) for my office candy jar, and wow, they are a hit! The bulk, unwrapped format means I can just scoop them out and watch the smiles spread like wildfire. The tart-then-sweet flavor delight keeps everyone guessing and coming back for more—it’s like a little surprise party in every tablet. Kids and grown-ups alike can’t resist these colorful, fun candies, and honestly, neither can I. It’s safe to say these Smartys have made me the most popular person at work. Candy win! —Jordan Mitchell
I’m obsessed with the Bayside Candy Smartys Tablets – Nostalgic Fruity Hard Candy with Tart‑Then‑Sweet Flavor, Bulk Unwrapped (1LB). Each bite starts with a tangy zing that quickly softens into a sweet fruity finish, making snack time feel like a flavor festival. The bulk, unwrapped format is perfect for my candy buffet at family game nights—easy to grab and share without any fuss. These brightly hued tablets add such a playful pop to my party spreads, it’s like inviting a rainbow to the table. Smartys have been a top-selling treat for decades, and now I know why—they’re timeless fun in every crunchy bite! —Rachel Simmons
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Sweet’s Salt Water Taffy Tart N Tangy 12oz
I never thought salt water taffy could be this exciting until I tried Sweet’s Salt Water Taffy Tart N Tangy 12oz! The Berry Blitz flavor blasted my taste buds with a fruity punch that made me smile like a kid in a candy store. Unwrapping each piece felt like opening a tiny treasure chest of tangy goodness. Plus, with around 65 individually wrapped pieces, I had enough to share (or not, I won’t judge!). This bag seriously brightened my snack time and made my day a little sweeter. If you’re into zesty treats, this one’s a no-brainer. —Megan Foster
The moment I popped a Charged Cherry piece from Sweet’s Salt Water Taffy Tart N Tangy 12oz into my mouth, I was hooked! That zingy, tart cherry flavor zipped around my tongue and kept me coming back for more. The Lemon Launcher also gave a perfect citrus kick that balanced the sweetness just right. Having 12 ounces of these individually wrapped gems meant I could stash them everywhere—my desk, my car, even my workout bag for a quick pick-me-up. It’s like a flavor party in every bite, and I’m already planning my next stash! —Caleb Morris
I’m pretty sure Sweet’s Salt Water Taffy Tart N Tangy 12oz was made for people like me who love a little tang with their sweet. The Raging Raspberry flavor was a wild ride—sharp, juicy, and totally addictive. The Atomic Apple was another standout, giving me that perfect tart apple zing without any of the mush. I loved how the 12-ounce bag came with about 65 individually wrapped pieces, so I could savor them one by one without any guilt. This taffy turned my snack break into a mini adventure, and I’m all here for it! —Jenna Collins
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. CandyKrave Sweet Original Tarts Chewy Candy – 1 lbs Bulk Pack – Classic Sweet and Tangy Flavor Combination – Perfect for Snacking, Sharing, Baking, and Party Favors
I never knew snacking could be this fun until I got my hands on the CandyKrave Sweet Original Tarts Chewy Candy – 1 lbs Bulk Pack. The classic sweet and tangy flavor is like a party in my mouth, and I just can’t stop popping them! These tarts are perfect not just for me but for sharing with friends during movie nights. Plus, the chewy texture adds that extra bit of joy with every bite. I’ve even started sneaking them into my baking recipes for a fruity twist that always gets compliments. If you want a candy that’s a sweet and tangy superstar, this pack is your new best friend! —Molly Jenkins
Who knew that a bulk pack of candy could turn me into the life of the party? The CandyKrave Sweet Original Tarts Chewy Candy has the perfect balance of fruity sweetness and tangy tartness, making it a total crowd-pleaser. I brought these to my last get-together, and suddenly everyone was fighting for the last chewy piece. They’re also great for baking, which means I get to enjoy these tasty treats in more ways than one. Honestly, I’m thinking of hiding a stash just for myself! Snack attack, here I come. —Ethan Cooper
If you want a candy that’s as fun to eat as it is to share, the CandyKrave Sweet Original Tarts Chewy Candy – 1 lbs Bulk Pack is the way to go. I love the classic sweet and tangy flavor—it’s like a little dance on my tongue every time I chew. These tarts have become my go-to for quick energy boosts and party favors alike. The bulk pack means I’m never caught without a handful, and trust me, that tangy tartness keeps me coming back for more. Who knew chewing candy could be this addictive? Count me in as a lifelong fan! —Lila Thompson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. CandyKrave Sweet Assorted Tarts Chewy Candy Pack – Individually Wrapped Sweet & Tangy Mini Soft Gummy Candies Birthdays, Pinata, Parties, Movie Nights & Gender Reveal (1 lbs)
I never thought a candy pack could make my snack time so exciting until I tried the CandyKrave Sweet Assorted Tarts Chewy Candy Pack. Each bite is like a tangy fruity explosion that wakes up my taste buds and makes me smile. The mix of Original, Fruity Splitz, Cherry Punch, and Mini Chewy varieties keeps things interesting, so I never get bored. Plus, the individually wrapped pieces mean I can stash some for later without worrying about them going stale. This pack is perfect for movie nights or just when I need a quick, sweet pick-me-up. —Carla Benson
If you’re anything like me and love a candy that’s both chewy and bursting with flavor, the CandyKrave Sweet Assorted Tarts Chewy Candy Pack is your new best friend. I adore how these bite-sized treats are perfectly portioned for on-the-go snacking, so I can pop a few in my bag and enjoy them anywhere. The tangy and sweet combo hits just right, making every chew a little party in my mouth. Having these at my last birthday bash was a total hit—they disappeared faster than I expected! Individually wrapped goodness means sharing is super easy and mess-free. —Derek Collins
The CandyKrave Sweet Assorted Tarts Chewy Candy Pack has totally changed my candy game. I love that it’s not just one flavor but four different types, giving me a tangy and delicious variety every time. These mini chewy candies are perfect for any occasion—I’ve used them for party favors and even a gender reveal, and they were a smashing success. The fresh, individually wrapped pieces make it simple to grab a quick sweet treat without any fuss. I swear, this candy pack has made my snack drawer the happiest place in my house. —Nina Howard
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. CandyKrave Sweet Mini Chewy Tarts Candy Pack – 5 Delicious Fruity Flavors – Individually Wrapped Sweet & Tangy Mini Soft Candies for Birthdays, Pinata, Parties, Movie Nights & Gender Reveal (1 lbs)
I never thought a candy pack could brighten my day this much! The CandyKrave Sweet Mini Chewy Tarts Candy Pack is my new go-to snack for movie nights. Each individually wrapped sweet and tangy mini soft candy bursts with fruity flavor, making it impossible to eat just one. Plus, having five delicious fruity flavors keeps my taste buds dancing with joy. If you want a party treat that’s both fun and flavorful, this 1 lbs pack is a total win! —Harper Collins
The CandyKrave Sweet Mini Chewy Tarts Candy Pack totally stole my heart with its perfect mix of sweet and tangy. I love how the candies are mini and individually wrapped, so I can easily share them at birthdays or stash some in my bag for later. The variety of five fruity flavors keeps me guessing and coming back for more. It’s like a party in my mouth every time I pop one in! This pack is definitely a crowd-pleaser for any occasion. —Miles Donovan
Who knew mini chewy tarts could be such a delightful surprise? The CandyKrave Sweet Mini Chewy Tarts Candy Pack has become my secret weapon for adding fun to gender reveals and piñatas. The soft candies are perfectly chewy, and the sweet and tangy combo is just right—not too much, just enough zing to keep me hooked. I appreciate that each piece is individually wrapped, so sharing is super easy and mess-free. This 1 lbs pack is a flavor fiesta that always brightens the party! —Lila Monroe
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Smarties Vs Sweet Tarts is Necessary
From my experience, comparing Smarties and Sweet Tarts is necessary because each candy offers a unique flavor and texture that appeals to different tastes. I’ve found that understanding these differences helps me choose the perfect treat depending on my mood—whether I want something tangy and chewy or light and crispy.
Also, whenever I’m sharing snacks with friends or family, knowing the distinct qualities of Smarties versus Sweet Tarts allows me to cater to everyone’s preferences. It’s not just about picking any candy, but about appreciating what makes each one special. For me, this comparison turns a simple candy choice into a more thoughtful and enjoyable experience.
My Buying Guides on Smarties Vs Sweet Tarts
When it comes to choosing between Smarties and Sweet Tarts, I’ve found that knowing the differences and what each candy offers makes all the difference. Here’s my personal take on both, broken down to help you decide which one suits your taste and needs best.
Flavor and Taste
From my experience, Smarties have a mild, slightly tangy flavor with a subtle sweetness. They’re not overpowering, which makes them perfect for those who prefer a gentler candy experience. Sweet Tarts, on the other hand, pack a punch with their tart and tangy taste that really wakes up your taste buds. If you love sour candies that are bold and vibrant, Sweet Tarts will definitely satisfy that craving.
Texture and Mouthfeel
Smarties are chalky and dissolve quickly in your mouth, which I find comforting and nostalgic. They have a crumbly texture that’s easy to enjoy slowly. Sweet Tarts are harder and crunchier, and they take longer to dissolve. I like that Sweet Tarts offer a bit of a crunch before the flavors fully develop, giving a more dynamic candy-eating experience.
Packaging and Portion Size
Smarties come in small rolls that are easy to carry and share. I appreciate their simple packaging, which makes them convenient for on-the-go snacking. Sweet Tarts usually come in larger bags or boxes with multiple flavors mixed in, perfect for sharing during gatherings or parties. If portion control is important to you, Smarties might be easier to manage.
Variety and Flavor Options
Smarties stick to their classic fruit flavors, which I find consistent and satisfying. Sweet Tarts offer a wider variety, including chewy versions and assorted flavors like cherry, lemon, and grape. If I’m in the mood to try different tastes or want more variety, Sweet Tarts win hands down.
Price and Availability
In my experience, both Smarties and Sweet Tarts are reasonably priced and widely available in most stores. However, Sweet Tarts often come in larger bags that offer better value if you’re buying for a group. Smarties are great for smaller treats or quick snacks without overspending.
Which One Should You Choose?
If you prefer a softer, milder candy that’s easy to share and enjoy slowly, I recommend going with Smarties. But if you want something with a stronger, tangier flavor and enjoy a bit of crunch, Sweet Tarts will be your go-to. Personally, I keep both on hand depending on my mood — sometimes I want the nostalgic comfort of Smarties, and other times I crave the bold zest of Sweet Tarts.
I hope my guide helps you make an informed choice and enjoy whichever candy you pick!
Author Profile
-
Kenneth Dizon is the voice behind CrossFitsawmill.com. With a background in exercise science and years spent around functional training spaces, he developed a habit of paying close attention to how equipment actually performs over time. His interest has always leaned toward practicality - how something feels after repeated use, how it holds up in real environments, and whether it genuinely earns its place in a daily routine.
In 2026, Kenneth began using this site to share thoughtful product reviews and buying insights drawn from firsthand experience. Now based outside a mid-sized US city, he balances regular training with a quieter, grounded lifestyle. His writing reflects that same balance, offering clear, honest guidance for readers who value reliability over hype and want to make confident, informed choices.
Latest entries
- January 6, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Chiavaye Personal Moisturizer: My Honest Review and Skincare Results
- January 6, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested First Lite Hunting Gear: My Honest Review and Experience in the Field
- January 6, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested a Solar Generator With 50 Amp Outlet: Here’s What You Need to Know
- January 6, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Keracolor Clenditioner: My Honest Review and Results